Issues

• [Decision] Who presses Start Signing? Records holds the capability but cannot read an approved contract, legal can read it but lacks the capability, and clm_admin cannot write the contract

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#100 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026

• Seven smaller things a real user hits (from the 17.7.0 browser pass): legal tabs shown to requesters, a template toggle with no template, renewal with no link, orphan drafts, a false demo note, an empty landing page for lawyers

  pm:dispatched
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#99 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

  

• A requester's own uploaded contract version shows "no file" — sys_file read answers 403 for the audiences that can read the version

  pm:blocked
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#98 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

• The renewal-notice and expiration-sweep jobs produce nothing although 11 contracts carry is_expiring, and five of the six daily flows report acted: 0 while they notify

  pm:dispatched
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#97 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

  

• The contract page's new-version form defaults "Current" off, and two versions of one contract can both be current

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#96 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

• Implementation notes are shown to users as help text — field and dashboard-widget descriptions cite hook files, card numbers, DESIGN.md sections and PRs

  pm:dispatched
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#95 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

  

• Header lifecycle actions succeed and the contract page keeps showing the old status and the old button until a manual reload

  pm:queue
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#94 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026

• On a README-configured install the approval ladder sticks forever at its first rung — manager_review resolves to manager:undefined, locks the contract, and no approver is told anything is waiting

  pm:dispatched
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#93 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

  

• The intake wizard's "Submit now" fails for every requester — FLOW_FAILED, the edit-window RLS policy refuses the post-submit row, while the header Submit button on the same draft succeeds

  pm:dispatched
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#90 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 10, 2026
  3

  

• A business requester and a legal counsel get "You don't have permission" on the contract's Discussion tab and a blank Approvals tab — sys_activity / sys_comment / sys_attachment / sys_approval_request answer 403

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#86 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 9, 2026
  5

• Card 13 — AI participation: S1–S6 skills, the pre-review memo, MCP tool surface, honest degradation (M4)

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#84 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 9, 2026
  1

• Card 12 — F8 e-signature connector · F15 HotCRM hand-off behind CLM_COMPOSITION (M4)

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#83 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 9, 2026
  1

• Upgrade the @objectstack/* dependencies from 17.4.0 to 17.7.0, walking the official upgrade checklists of 17.5, 17.6 and 17.7

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#82 · Filter by author objectstack-fleet opened on Oct 9, 2026
  5

• The two surfaces that merely restate the gate set should name pnpm verify instead of enumerating it — a restatement of a definition cannot be allowed to drift

  pm:dispatched
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#78 · Filter by author zhuangjianguo opened on Sep 10, 2026
  3

  

• DESIGN.md §04 gives clm_requester update on its own obligations, and controlled_by_parent refuses it for all 200 — 我负责的履约 is read-only for the audience it is built for

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#64 · Filter by author claude opened on Sep 10, 2026
  2

• 34 backfilled contracts carry a legal_owner, and is_backfilled says on the same row that no review ever happened

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#53 · Filter by author zhuangjianguo opened on Sep 10, 2026
  1

• [Decision] §06 F16 说补录动作「档案岗**或**法务可用」，但实现只能给档案岗——权限是 AND，没有两边都持有的能力

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#43 · Filter by author zhuangjianguo opened on Sep 9, 2026

• pnpm demo stops being re-runnable once the daily jobs have run: the seed re-asserts statuses the state machines refuse to go back to

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#41 · Filter by author zhuangjianguo opened on Sep 9, 2026
  5

• [Decision] 17.4 的新规则指出 21 个字段声明了却没人读——展品该给它们消费者，还是删掉声明

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#38 · Filter by author zhuangjianguo opened on Sep 9, 2026

• [PM seat] repo:hotclm — ⏳ vacant

  pm:seat
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#36 · Filter by author zhuangjianguo opened on Sep 9, 2026
  6

• [Decision] §09 要「各段时长」和「超 SLA」，但语义层算不出时间差——两问共用一个补法

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#31 · Filter by author hotlong opened on Sep 7, 2026
  6

• [Decision] pnpm demo 开箱即用时没有任何账号能打开「我的合同」——要不要让脚本建账号，与 #11 第一问耦合

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#28 · Filter by author hotlong opened on Sep 7, 2026
  2

• Decision: §10 wants a multi-entity group, but clm_contract.our_entity ships exactly one option and a seed cannot add one

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#20 · Filter by author hotlong opened on Sep 7, 2026
  1

• Decision: DESIGN.md §10 asks for 300 seeded contract versions, but §03 makes file required and a seed cannot mint one

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#19 · Filter by author hotlong opened on Sep 7, 2026
  1

• [Decision] DESIGN.md §04 makes clm_requester every employee's default, but a set that grants clm_requester.access cannot bind to everyone

  needs-user-decision
  objectstack-ai/hotclm#11 · Filter by author hotlong opened on Sep 7, 2026
  3