From b32f43fe72d77ff3f2b0825fb47566a136dd1188 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Brett Heap Date: Sat, 17 Oct 2026 20:58:18 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/5] Hygiene rule: a host path under the bench root is a finding, with one allowance for a path inside a quoted grep pattern Part of #193 (item 22). tests/test_repo_hygiene.py's host-path rule matched /home//, /Users//, the Claude scratchpad prefix and a Windows user profile, and never the bench root, so two committed files carried 87 such lines that only a person's eye had checked. host_absolute_path_hits() now also reports every line that names the bench root at the start of a path, except inside a single-quoted search pattern of a grep (the first quoted operand after grep and its short flags, and each further -e argument), because a recorded search must keep the text it searched for. A path beside the pattern, a second quoted operand, a double-quoted pattern, and a flag that takes a value are all still findings. Red and green tests plant the path in twelve places the allowance must not reach and nine forms it must accept, replay the three recorded searches of consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md as main carries them (red) and with the root beside the pattern made a placeholder (green), and hold the home-directory rule as it was. On this commit the repository test is red on exactly the two files whose placeholders follow in the next two commits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- tests/test_repo_hygiene.py | 191 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 189 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py b/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py index ca3cd0d7..d9adfb34 100644 --- a/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py +++ b/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py @@ -2497,6 +2497,58 @@ def test_readme_is_short_enough_to_be_read(): r"|C:\\Users\\(?!runneradmin\\)[^\s\\]+\\" ) +#: THE BENCH ROOT, A RULE OF ITS OWN (opensoft/openRepoTools#193, item 22). A +#: path under a bench's root names one machine as surely as a home directory +#: does, and the rule above never matched it: 87 lines in two committed files +#: carried one, checked by a person's eye alone. It is a second pattern, and +#: not a fifth alternative above, because it has an allowance the first rule +#: has no use for (`QUOTED_SEARCH_PATTERNS`, below). +#: +#: The pattern wants the root at the START of a path. Nothing that continues a +#: path segment (a word character), a home directory (`~`), a variable (`$`, +#: `}`) or a relative walk (`.`) may stand directly before it, so a relative +#: `templates//` directory called `workspace`, or `~/workspace/…`, is not +#: this bench's root and is not a finding. The root's name carries the trailing +#: slash on purpose: `workspace.yaml` and `workspace-root/` are not it. +#: +#: THE ROOT IS SPELLED IN TWO PIECES for the reason `_CLAUDE_TMP_PREFIX` is: +#: this file is scanned like every other, and a contiguous spelling here would +#: be a finding in the very file that defines the rule. +_BENCH_ROOT = "/work" + "space/" +BENCH_ABSOLUTE_PATH = re.compile(r"(?/…'` says what was searched for, and swapping a placeholder +#: into it would make the record claim a different search. Three lines of +#: `specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md` are exactly that. +#: +#: It is narrow on purpose. An allowed span is a SINGLE-QUOTED string (the shell +#: expands nothing in one, so it is plainly a literal) that is +#: - the first quoted operand after a `grep` word and its short flags, as in +#: `grep -rn '^path: …'` and `grep -E '…'` (`git grep -n -e '…'` is this +#: form too: `-e` reads as one more flag), or +#: - the argument of a further `-e`, as in `grep -n -e 'a' -e 'b'`. +#: Everything else stays a finding: a second quoted operand is a FILE (`grep -n +#: 'x' ''`), a double-quoted string can hold a variable, a flag that takes +#: a value (`grep -m 1 '…'`) ends the run of flags, and a path before the +#: `grep` (`git -C grep …`) is outside it. Within a line only: no +#: whitespace in these patterns may be a newline. +QUOTED_SEARCH_PATTERNS = re.compile( + r"\bgrep(?:[ \t]+-[A-Za-z]+)*[ \t]+'[^'\n]*'(?:[ \t]+-e[ \t]+'[^'\n]*')*") + + +def host_absolute_path_hits(text: str) -> list[str]: + """Every host-absolute path in `text`: the matched strings of + `HOST_ABSOLUTE_PATH`, then one `line N: ` for each line that + names the bench root outside a quoted search pattern. A bare `[]` means the + text is clean.""" + hits = HOST_ABSOLUTE_PATH.findall(text) + for number, line in enumerate(text.splitlines(), 1): + scrubbed = QUOTED_SEARCH_PATTERNS.sub("grep", line) + if BENCH_ABSOLUTE_PATH.search(scrubbed): + hits.append(f"line {number}: {line.strip()[:120]}") + return hits + def _dispatcher_arms(text: str) -> list[str]: """Every subcommand the main dispatcher has an arm for, in file order. @@ -2881,6 +2933,11 @@ def test_no_committed_file_names_a_host_absolute_path(): assembly and the spec leg beside the code leg, which is every file the one repository carried before the split. Their gitlinks are paths and not files, like the one above. + + THE BENCH ROOT IS A HOST PATH TOO (opensoft/openRepoTools#193, item 22): + `host_absolute_path_hits` reads it beside the home-directory forms, with + one allowance, a path inside a quoted `grep` search pattern. The tests + after this one hold both halves of that rule, red and green. """ offenders = {} for rel, path in tracked_files(): @@ -2890,13 +2947,143 @@ def test_no_committed_file_names_a_host_absolute_path(): text = path.read_bytes().decode("utf-8") except UnicodeDecodeError: continue - hits = HOST_ABSOLUTE_PATH.findall(text) + hits = host_absolute_path_hits(text) if hits: - offenders[rel] = hits + # FIVE PER FILE: a file with eighty-six findings should say so, not + # print them all into one assertion. + offenders[rel] = (hits if len(hits) <= 5 + else hits[:5] + [f"... and {len(hits) - 5} more"]) assert not offenders, ( f"committed file(s) name a host-absolute path: {offenders}") +def _plant(template: str) -> str: + """`template` with `` replaced by the bench root. The rule's own + constant fills it, so this file never spells the root contiguously and the + scan above has nothing of its own to find.""" + return template.replace("", _BENCH_ROOT) + + +#: TEXT THE BENCH-ROOT RULE MUST REFUSE. Each row is (why, text). +BENCH_PATH_REFUSED = [ + ("a path as a command's operand", + "cat projects/x/file"), + ("a path in a yaml value, the shape of the ideation sample", + "directory: projects/openRepoTools"), + ("a path in prose and in a table cell", + "| `projects/openRepoTools/handoffs` | the checkout's symlink |"), + ("a path as `git -C` argument, though the same line quotes a pattern", + "git -C projects/x grep -n -e 'projects/y' HEAD -- ."), + ("a quoted path that is not a search pattern", + "ls 'projects/x'"), + ("a second quoted operand of grep, which is a file", + "grep -n 'x' 'projects/x/file'"), + ("a path after the pattern, which is the file searched", + "grep -n 'projects/x' projects/y"), + ("a double-quoted pattern, which can hold a variable", + 'grep -E "projects/x" file'), + ("a flag that takes a value ends the run of flags", + "grep -m 1 'projects/x' file"), + ("a quoted path piped INTO a grep is still an echoed path", + "echo 'projects/x' | grep -n 'y'"), + ("a grep on one line licenses nothing on the next", + "grep -n\n'projects/x' file"), + ("a file:// URL names the same host path", + "file://projects/x"), +] + +#: TEXT IT MUST ACCEPT. The first five are the allowance, each in one of the +#: shapes a recorded search takes; the rest are look-alikes that are not the +#: bench's root at all. +BENCH_PATH_ACCEPTED = [ + ("grep -E with a quoted pattern", + "grep -E 'projects/x' file"), + ("grep -rn with an anchored pattern and a placeholder for the files", + "grep -rn '^path: projects/openRepoTools/' $LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} | wc -l"), + ("git grep with several -e patterns and a placeholder for the checkout", + "git -C $WB grep -n -e 'projects/openRepoTools' " + "-e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\\.lane-worktrees' HEAD -- ."), + ("a later -e carries the path", + "grep -n -e 'a' -e 'projects/x' file"), + ("a pattern after a pipe", + "git show HEAD:x | grep -n 'projects/x'"), + ("a placeholder is not a path", + "git -C $ORT rev-parse HEAD"), + ("a path under the home directory, by tilde, $HOME and ${HOME}", + "~x $HOMEx ${HOME}x"), + ("a relative directory that happens to carry the root's name", + "templatesx ..x .x"), + ("the workspace record and a template directory are not the root", + "~/.agents/workspace.yaml and templates/workspace-root/ and workspace/"), +] + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("why,template", BENCH_PATH_REFUSED, + ids=[why for why, _ in BENCH_PATH_REFUSED]) +def test_the_bench_root_rule_is_red_on_a_planted_path(why, template): + """RED: a path at the bench's root is a finding wherever it stands, except + inside a quoted search pattern. Every row plants one in a place the + allowance must NOT reach, and `git -C grep -e ''` is the row + that matters most: the first path is as host-absolute as ever, and the + pattern beside it licenses nothing.""" + hits = host_absolute_path_hits(_plant(template)) + assert hits, f"the rule let this through ({why}): {_plant(template)!r}" + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("why,template", BENCH_PATH_ACCEPTED, + ids=[why for why, _ in BENCH_PATH_ACCEPTED]) +def test_the_bench_root_rule_is_green_on_the_allowed_forms(why, template): + """GREEN: a path inside a quoted search pattern is the recorded command's + own text and stays; so does everything that merely resembles the root.""" + text = _plant(template) + assert host_absolute_path_hits(text) == [], ( + f"the rule refused this ({why}): {text!r}") + + +def test_the_quoted_pattern_allowance_scrubs_the_pattern_and_nothing_beside_it(): + """One line, two roots: the allowance takes the quoted pattern out of the + line and the other path stays a finding, reported by line number.""" + line = _plant("git -C projects/x grep -n -e 'projects/y' HEAD") + hits = host_absolute_path_hits("fine\n" + line + "\nalso fine\n") + assert len(hits) == 1 and hits[0].startswith("line 2: git -C "), hits + + +def test_the_consumer_reads_search_lines_are_red_as_main_carried_them_and_green_fixed(): + """The three recorded searches of `consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md` (lines 94, + 132 and 142 on main), each as #189 landed it and as it reads once the root + BESIDE the pattern is a placeholder. The pattern itself is byte for byte + the same in both, which is the whole claim: a placeholder in it would have + changed what the command searched for.""" + pairs = [ + ("git -C projects/workBenches grep -n -e 'projects/openRepoTools'" + " -e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\\.lane-worktrees' HEAD -- .", + "git -C $WB grep -n -e 'projects/openRepoTools'" + " -e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\\.lane-worktrees' HEAD -- ."), + ("git -C projects/brett-wip grep -n -e 'projects/openRepoTools'" + " -e '~/projects/openRepoTools' ab88a10 -- . # 341 lines", + "git -C $BW grep -n -e 'projects/openRepoTools'" + " -e '~/projects/openRepoTools' ab88a10 -- . # 341 lines"), + ("grep -rn '^path: projects/openRepoTools/'" + " projects/.lane-state/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} | wc -l", + "grep -rn '^path: projects/openRepoTools/'" + " $LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} | wc -l"), + ] + for before, after in pairs: + assert host_absolute_path_hits(_plant(before)), _plant(before) + assert host_absolute_path_hits(_plant(after)) == [], _plant(after) + + +def test_the_bench_rule_leaves_the_home_directory_rule_as_it_was(): + """The bench root is a second pattern beside the first, not an edit of it: + the home-directory forms are still found, and the Windows runner's own + account is still the one exemption.""" + unix = "/home" + "/alice/" + mac = "/Users" + "/Bob/" + assert host_absolute_path_hits(unix + "x") == [unix] + assert host_absolute_path_hits(mac + "x") == [mac] + assert host_absolute_path_hits("C:" + "\\Users\\runneradmin\\x") == [] + + def test_the_root_carries_the_line_ending_rule(): """`* text=auto eol=lf`, for openRepoShape's reason retold for this repository: `openRepoTools --install` compares the bytes it is about to From 064c2ae47785aa04413cd69c59f01c8bbe0617e9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Brett Heap Date: Sat, 17 Oct 2026 21:00:07 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/5] consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md: name the bench paths by placeholder, defined once, and keep the three quoted search patterns as typed MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Part of #193 (item 22). Eighty-six lines of lane 2's consumer-side reads (landed in #189) named a host-absolute path under the bench root, in the "Exact commands" listing and in table and prose rows, across six roots. They now read $WB (workBenches), $BW (brett-wip), $LS (the lane-state root), $XF (xFactory), $ORT (the openRepoTools checkout), $ORTW (the openRepoTools-worktrees root) and $READS (lane 2's worktree of the planning branch), plus $PROJECTS for the one row that says what ~/projects is. All eight are defined once, in one paragraph added under the opening note. The three recorded searches whose pattern is a path (`grep -e '…/openRepoTools'` in the workBenches and brett-wip listings and `grep -rn '^path: …/openRepoTools/'` over the lane-state records) keep that pattern byte for byte, because a placeholder would change what was searched for; only the root beside each pattern is a placeholder, and the hygiene rule's quoted-pattern allowance accepts them. Nothing else changed: no finding, number, sha or result is reworded. Expanding the placeholders back and dropping the added paragraph reproduces main's file byte for byte. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- .../consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md | 185 ++++++++++-------- 1 file changed, 99 insertions(+), 86 deletions(-) diff --git a/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md b/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md index 4abffbff..5734da37 100644 --- a/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md +++ b/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md @@ -2,6 +2,19 @@ Paths under the home directory are written portably (`~/`) because the repository's hygiene test refuses host-absolute paths in committed files; the originals are in lane 2's transcript. +Bench paths are written as placeholders, defined here once, for the same reason. Each is a directory on the bench where the reads ran, and the commands below need them as shell variables: + +- `$PROJECTS`: the bench's projects directory, the one `~/projects` stood for there. +- `$WB`: the workBenches checkout, `$PROJECTS/workBenches`. +- `$BW`: the brett-wip checkout, `$PROJECTS/brett-wip`. +- `$LS`: the lane-state root, `$PROJECTS/.lane-state`. +- `$XF`: the xFactory checkout, `$PROJECTS/xFactory`. +- `$ORT`: the openRepoTools checkout, `$PROJECTS/openRepoTools`. +- `$ORTW`: the openRepoTools-worktrees root, where Brett Heap's feature worktrees for openRepoTools live, `$PROJECTS/openRepoTools-worktrees`. +- `$READS`: lane 2's worktree of the planning branch, `$PROJECTS/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads`. + +Three recorded searches keep a path inside a single-quoted `grep` pattern exactly as it was typed (the workBenches and brett-wip `grep -e '…'` lines, and the `.lane-state` count), because a placeholder in the pattern would change what was searched for. The hygiene test allows a path inside a quoted `grep` pattern and nowhere else. The paths these placeholders stand for are in lane 2's transcript and in this file as #189 landed it. + Read at 2026-10-07T10:04:44Z–11:07:10Z by lane openRepoTools-2's writer, under #186, from ff6f6a7. An API-side error cut the run, and it resumed at 11:03:49Z, when every head was checked again. HEADs read: @@ -41,68 +54,68 @@ Plan files (lane 2's worktree, same commit as the planning branch): ```sh date -u +%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ -git -C /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads rev-parse HEAD -git -C /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads status --short -cat -n /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads/openspec/changes/migrate-to-triad/adoption-plan.yaml -cat -n /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/installer-design.md -cat -n /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/tasks.md -cat -n /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/plan.md -cat -n /workspace/projects/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/spec.md +git -C $READS rev-parse HEAD +git -C $READS status --short +cat -n $READS/openspec/changes/migrate-to-triad/adoption-plan.yaml +cat -n $READS/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/installer-design.md +cat -n $READS/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/tasks.md +cat -n $READS/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/plan.md +cat -n $READS/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/spec.md ``` openRepoTools main (read-only; no fetch): ```sh -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools rev-parse main c4864ac -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools ls-tree --name-only c4864ac -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools ls-tree -r --name-only c4864ac | wc -l # 100 -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools ls-tree -r --name-only daed20957f2dd2f22cca24053bb5bc8636ff6b3f | wc -l # 64 -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools diff --name-status daed20957f2dd2f22cca24053bb5bc8636ff6b3f c4864ac -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools ls-tree c4864ac upstream/openRepoShape -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:.gitmodules -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools ls-tree -r --name-only c4864ac contracts -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:openRepoTools > /openRepoTools.c4864ac +git -C $ORT rev-parse main c4864ac +git -C $ORT ls-tree --name-only c4864ac +git -C $ORT ls-tree -r --name-only c4864ac | wc -l # 100 +git -C $ORT ls-tree -r --name-only daed20957f2dd2f22cca24053bb5bc8636ff6b3f | wc -l # 64 +git -C $ORT diff --name-status daed20957f2dd2f22cca24053bb5bc8636ff6b3f c4864ac +git -C $ORT ls-tree c4864ac upstream/openRepoShape +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:.gitmodules +git -C $ORT ls-tree -r --name-only c4864ac contracts +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:openRepoTools > /openRepoTools.c4864ac grep -n 'raw.githubusercontent\|gh api\|OPENREPOTOOLS_REPO\|OPENREPOTOOLS_REF\|^REPO=\|^REF=\|INSTALLABLES\|repos.tsv\|SCRIPT_DIR\|script_dir\|BASH_SOURCE\|\$0' /openRepoTools.c4864ac grep -n 'selfdir\|skills/\|commands/\|contracts/\|upstream/\|docs/\|^[a-z_]*() *{' /openRepoTools.c4864ac sed -n '1,135p;136,440p;955,1002p;1210,1222p;1285,1368p;1365,1400p;2490,2545p' /openRepoTools.c4864ac -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools grep -n 'raw.githubusercontent\|gh api repos/opensoft/openRepoTools\|bash -s -- --install\|OPENREPOTOOLS_REF\|OPENREPOTOOLS_REPO' c4864ac -- README.md AGENTS.md docs -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:repos.tsv -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | grep -n 'repos.tsv' -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | grep -n '\.lane-state' -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lane-worktrees | grep -n 'inventor' -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lane-worktrees | sed -n '2120,2128p;2164,2175p;2708,2716p;4808,4822p' -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:link-estates | grep -n 'handoffs\|PROJECTS\|projects/\|estate' -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:.gitignore -for c in 2fb854f 5eb3d5f 500687c c4864ac; do git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show $c:openRepoTools | sha256sum; done -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lane-worktrees | sha256sum -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | sha256sum -ls -la /workspace/projects/openRepoTools -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools status --porcelain=v1 --ignored -cat /workspace/projects/openRepoTools/.git/info/exclude -stat -c '%y' /workspace/projects/openRepoTools/.git/index # 2026-10-07 04:28:20Z, before this read: the status call wrote no index +git -C $ORT grep -n 'raw.githubusercontent\|gh api repos/opensoft/openRepoTools\|bash -s -- --install\|OPENREPOTOOLS_REF\|OPENREPOTOOLS_REPO' c4864ac -- README.md AGENTS.md docs +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:repos.tsv +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | grep -n 'repos.tsv' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | grep -n '\.lane-state' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lane-worktrees | grep -n 'inventor' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lane-worktrees | sed -n '2120,2128p;2164,2175p;2708,2716p;4808,4822p' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:link-estates | grep -n 'handoffs\|PROJECTS\|projects/\|estate' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:.gitignore +for c in 2fb854f 5eb3d5f 500687c c4864ac; do git -C $ORT show $c:openRepoTools | sha256sum; done +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lane-worktrees | sha256sum +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | sha256sum +ls -la $ORT +git -C $ORT status --porcelain=v1 --ignored +cat $ORT/.git/info/exclude +stat -c '%y' $ORT/.git/index # 2026-10-07 04:28:20Z, before this read: the status call wrote no index ``` workBenches (read-only; committed objects at HEAD `7fd01e3`): ```sh -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches rev-parse HEAD -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches status --porcelain=v1 # " M sysBenches/cloudBench" -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches worktree list -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:.gitmodules -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches submodule status -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches grep -n -i 'openRepoTools' HEAD -- . # 939 lines; per-file counts via cut | sort | uniq -c -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches grep -n -e '/workspace/projects/openRepoTools' -e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\.lane-worktrees' -e 'raw.githubusercontent.com/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'repos/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'github.com/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'opensoft/openRepoTools/' -e 'projects/openRepoTools' HEAD -- . -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/upstream-pin.yaml -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/Dockerfile | sed -n '136,285p' -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/update-upstream.py | sed -n '68,90p;886,960p' -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/files/estate/estate-commands-start -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/files/estate/workbench-entrypoint | grep -n 'estate-commands-start\|openrepotools\|exec' -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches ls-tree -r --name-only HEAD devBenches/base-image/files/openrepotools -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:scripts/setup-estate-commands.sh | grep -n -i 'openRepoTools\|vendor\|files/\|OPENREPOTOOLS\|INSTALLABLES\|skills/\|commands/\|755\|link-estates' -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:scripts/setup-estate-commands.sh | sed -n '158,200p;276,330p;370,405p' -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:setup.sh | sed -n '176,200p' -git -C /workspace/projects/workBenches show HEAD:README.md | sed -n '188p;190p' -stat -c '%y' /workspace/projects/workBenches/.git/index # 2026-10-06 13:08:26Z, before this read +git -C $WB rev-parse HEAD +git -C $WB status --porcelain=v1 # " M sysBenches/cloudBench" +git -C $WB worktree list +git -C $WB show HEAD:.gitmodules +git -C $WB submodule status +git -C $WB grep -n -i 'openRepoTools' HEAD -- . # 939 lines; per-file counts via cut | sort | uniq -c +git -C $WB grep -n -e '/workspace/projects/openRepoTools' -e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\.lane-worktrees' -e 'raw.githubusercontent.com/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'repos/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'github.com/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'opensoft/openRepoTools/' -e 'projects/openRepoTools' HEAD -- . +git -C $WB show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/upstream-pin.yaml +git -C $WB show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/Dockerfile | sed -n '136,285p' +git -C $WB show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/update-upstream.py | sed -n '68,90p;886,960p' +git -C $WB show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/files/estate/estate-commands-start +git -C $WB show HEAD:devBenches/base-image/files/estate/workbench-entrypoint | grep -n 'estate-commands-start\|openrepotools\|exec' +git -C $WB ls-tree -r --name-only HEAD devBenches/base-image/files/openrepotools +git -C $WB show HEAD:scripts/setup-estate-commands.sh | grep -n -i 'openRepoTools\|vendor\|files/\|OPENREPOTOOLS\|INSTALLABLES\|skills/\|commands/\|755\|link-estates' +git -C $WB show HEAD:scripts/setup-estate-commands.sh | sed -n '158,200p;276,330p;370,405p' +git -C $WB show HEAD:setup.sh | sed -n '176,200p' +git -C $WB show HEAD:README.md | sed -n '188p;190p' +stat -c '%y' $WB/.git/index # 2026-10-06 13:08:26Z, before this read ``` openRepoShape at 7f84ca4 (bare clone in lane 2's scratchpad, `ors-verify/ors.git`): @@ -124,22 +137,22 @@ git -C grep -n -i 'openRepoTools' 7f84ca42ca86a8902928345109d2bf6bad87 brett-wip (read-only; reads pinned at `ab88a10`): ```sh -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip rev-parse HEAD -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip status --porcelain=v1 | wc -l # 215, all untracked -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip ls-tree --name-only HEAD -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip ls-tree HEAD lanes/ -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip ls-tree -r --name-only HEAD | grep -i 'workspace.yaml' # none -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip grep -n -e '/workspace/projects/openRepoTools' -e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools' -e '~/projects/openRepoTools' -e 'projects/openRepoTools' ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67 -- . # 341 lines -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:lanes/LANES.md" > /LANES.md +git -C $BW rev-parse HEAD +git -C $BW status --porcelain=v1 | wc -l # 215, all untracked +git -C $BW ls-tree --name-only HEAD +git -C $BW ls-tree HEAD lanes/ +git -C $BW ls-tree -r --name-only HEAD | grep -i 'workspace.yaml' # none +git -C $BW grep -n -e '/workspace/projects/openRepoTools' -e 'openRepoTools-worktrees' -e '\.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools' -e '~/projects/openRepoTools' -e 'projects/openRepoTools' ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67 -- . # 341 lines +git -C $BW show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:lanes/LANES.md" > /LANES.md grep -n '^| lane\|^| `openRepoTools' /LANES.md -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md" # likewise -2, -3; sampled lines -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:lanes/repos.tsv" | sha256sum -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip grep -n -e '\.local/bin/\(openRepoTools\|park\|resume\|status\|lane\|lanes\|lane-handoff\|lane-rename\|lanes-edit\.sh\|lane-start\|lane-end\|link-estates\|repos\.tsv\|claude-current\|claude-restart-check\|lanes-index\|lane-worktrees\)\b' -e 'share/openRepoTools' -e 'raw.githubusercontent.com/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'docs/README-lanes' -e 'openRepoTools-\(code\|spec\)' ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67 -- . -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip grep -n -i -e 'openRepoTools' -e '\.local/bin' HEAD -- README.md AGENTS.md CLAUDE.md scripts/link-estates -ls -la /workspace/projects/xFactory/lanes-edit.sh /workspace/projects/xFactory/LANES.md -find /workspace/projects/.lane-state/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} -type f -grep -rn '^checkout:' /workspace/projects/.lane-state/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} -grep -rn '^path: /workspace/projects/openRepoTools/' /workspace/projects/.lane-state/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} | wc -l +git -C $BW show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md" # likewise -2, -3; sampled lines +git -C $BW show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:lanes/repos.tsv" | sha256sum +git -C $BW grep -n -e '\.local/bin/\(openRepoTools\|park\|resume\|status\|lane\|lanes\|lane-handoff\|lane-rename\|lanes-edit\.sh\|lane-start\|lane-end\|link-estates\|repos\.tsv\|claude-current\|claude-restart-check\|lanes-index\|lane-worktrees\)\b' -e 'share/openRepoTools' -e 'raw.githubusercontent.com/opensoft/openRepoTools' -e 'docs/README-lanes' -e 'openRepoTools-\(code\|spec\)' ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67 -- . +git -C $BW grep -n -i -e 'openRepoTools' -e '\.local/bin' HEAD -- README.md AGENTS.md CLAUDE.md scripts/link-estates +ls -la $XF/lanes-edit.sh $XF/LANES.md +find $LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} -type f +grep -rn '^checkout:' $LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} +grep -rn '^path: /workspace/projects/openRepoTools/' $LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3} | wc -l ``` `~/.agents` and the home directory: @@ -176,8 +189,8 @@ sed -n '318,336p' ~/.claude/skills/handoff/SKILL.md | `base-image/files/claude-profile:54-55, 557, 1649-1653`; `scripts/setup-claude-profiles.sh:213-224` | Matches the guard hook string byte for byte with openRepoTools's `GUARD_COMMAND` (cited as `openRepoTools:460-461`). Parses `openRepoTools --help`. Its install act is the string `openRepoTools --install`. Says `--install` owns the skill and command destinations. | Only installed names, help text, hook strings and destinations are read. The `openRepoTools:` cites point into a file that moves to `code/`. | covered: l.59, l.75, l.86 | | `README.md:80, 93, 155-156, 172, 188, 190` | "the lane tooling is installed from `opensoft/openRepoTools`" (`:188`); "places fifteen files" (`:190`). | The implementation moves to `openRepoTools-code`. The assembly keeps the slug and the one-liner (installer-design l.9-11). | not covered | | `devBenches/base-image/files/openreposhape/openRepoShape:83, 280` (openRepoShape pin `71cf5de`) | A vendored copy of openRepoShape's raw-URL pointer `…/opensoft/openRepoTools/main/openRepoTools` (see the openRepoShape table). | The URL resolves only if the assembly root carries an `openRepoTools` file (inferred). | covered: l.9-11, l.75 | -| `devBenches/base-image/files/openrepotools/lane-handoff:813, 913`; `…/lanes-edit.sh:11412, 11939`; `…/skills/handoff/SKILL.md:292` | Vendored openRepoTools code (`b1015f4`) derives `/.lane-worktrees/`. | The same as the code's own assumption (installer table, lane-worktrees row). It holds while lanes keep `dir /workspace/projects/openRepoTools` (inferred). | not covered | -| `devcontainer.test/test-setup-estate-commands.sh` (80 lines), `test-claude-profile-amendment-11.sh` (61), `test-setup-workspace-repo.sh` (52), and 8 more files under `devcontainer.test/` (57, including `README.md:70`); `test-claude-profile-lane-default.sh:282, 293`; `.github/workflows/speckit-git-bash.yml:19, 53` | The suites run or fake the vendored shim and its layout. `:282` and `:293` print `cwd /workspace/projects/openRepoTools`. The CI path filters are `devBenches/base-image/files/openrepotools/**`. | They follow whatever the vendored tree becomes. | not covered | +| `devBenches/base-image/files/openrepotools/lane-handoff:813, 913`; `…/lanes-edit.sh:11412, 11939`; `…/skills/handoff/SKILL.md:292` | Vendored openRepoTools code (`b1015f4`) derives `/.lane-worktrees/`. | The same as the code's own assumption (installer table, lane-worktrees row). It holds while lanes keep `dir $ORT` (inferred). | not covered | +| `devcontainer.test/test-setup-estate-commands.sh` (80 lines), `test-claude-profile-amendment-11.sh` (61), `test-setup-workspace-repo.sh` (52), and 8 more files under `devcontainer.test/` (57, including `README.md:70`); `test-claude-profile-lane-default.sh:282, 293`; `.github/workflows/speckit-git-bash.yml:19, 53` | The suites run or fake the vendored shim and its layout. `:282` and `:293` print `cwd $ORT`. The CI path filters are `devBenches/base-image/files/openrepotools/**`. | They follow whatever the vendored tree becomes. | not covered | | `docs/claude-multi-account-profiles.md` (20 lines; `:314` cites `:1559`, `:1568`, `:1579` of openRepoTools `63a74af`), `openspec/**` and `specs/**` (52 lines), `base-image/files/claude-statusline-command.sh:477`, `scripts/wave-container-shell.sh:55`, `files/speckit-worktree/…/resume.sh:451, 465`, `devBenches/devcontainer.test/test-speckit-git-feature.sh:3425, 3487` | Prose that names `opensoft/openRepoTools`, its issues, or file:line inside it. | The slug stays as the assembly. The files named move to `code/`. | not covered | ## openRepoShape (`7f84ca4`) @@ -199,18 +212,18 @@ openRepoShape pins nothing of openRepoTools. | file:line | what it assumes today | what the split changes | installer-design.md coverage | |---|---|---|---| -| `lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md:2`, `openRepoTools-2.md:2`, `openRepoTools-3.md:59` … (52 lines: 11 + 11 + 30) | STARTED, RESUMED and PAUSED records carry `home opensoft/openRepoTools; estate openRepoTools; dir /workspace/projects/openRepoTools`. That is the directory a lane is relaunched in. | In-place adoption keeps the slug as the assembly. The checkout keeps holding only 6 root files plus `spec/` and `code/` (inferred). The executables a lane runs from the checkout root move to `code/`. | not covered (rebinding is plan.md:223-224, T018) | -| `lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md:19`, `openRepoTools-3.md:291`, `:405`; `openXfactory-3.md:60`, `openXfactory-5.md:390`, `openxfactory-1.md:169` (+ `:253, 324, 411`) — 10 lines | Notes that name `.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-1` and `-3`, `openRepoTools-cleanup-archives/…`, or `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools` as a working directory. | These are records of past acts. The paths stay valid while the assembly sits at the same path (inferred). | not covered | -| `lanes/LANES.md:1109` (`openRepoTools-3`), `:1303` (`openRepoTools-1`), `:2581` (`openRepoTools-2`) | The rows carry a handoff path `handoffs/openRepoTools/…` and no directory column (header `:76`). Only `:1109` names a checkout: `--dir ~/projects/openRepoTools`. `~/projects` → `/workspace/projects`. | The handoff paths are in brett-wip and unaffected. The estate name `openRepoTools` stays. | not covered | +| `lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md:2`, `openRepoTools-2.md:2`, `openRepoTools-3.md:59` … (52 lines: 11 + 11 + 30) | STARTED, RESUMED and PAUSED records carry `home opensoft/openRepoTools; estate openRepoTools; dir $ORT`. That is the directory a lane is relaunched in. | In-place adoption keeps the slug as the assembly. The checkout keeps holding only 6 root files plus `spec/` and `code/` (inferred). The executables a lane runs from the checkout root move to `code/`. | not covered (rebinding is plan.md:223-224, T018) | +| `lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md:19`, `openRepoTools-3.md:291`, `:405`; `openXfactory-3.md:60`, `openXfactory-5.md:390`, `openxfactory-1.md:169` (+ `:253, 324, 411`) — 10 lines | Notes that name `.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-1` and `-3`, `openRepoTools-cleanup-archives/…`, or `$ORT` as a working directory. | These are records of past acts. The paths stay valid while the assembly sits at the same path (inferred). | not covered | +| `lanes/LANES.md:1109` (`openRepoTools-3`), `:1303` (`openRepoTools-1`), `:2581` (`openRepoTools-2`) | The rows carry a handoff path `handoffs/openRepoTools/…` and no directory column (header `:76`). Only `:1109` names a checkout: `--dir ~/projects/openRepoTools`. `~/projects` → `$PROJECTS`. | The handoff paths are in brett-wip and unaffected. The estate name `openRepoTools` stays. | not covered | | `lanes/LANES.md:36` (and `:1305`); 12 `docs/README-lanes` lines in 9 files (first: `handoffs/openRepoTools/brief-lane-openRepoTools-1-2026-09-16.md:9`, `session-handoff-2026-09-16-lane-openRepoTools-1.md:33`, `lanes/log/openRepoTools-1.md:22`) | "the manual lives at `docs/README-lanes.md` in `opensoft/openRepoTools`". | `docs/` moves to `openRepoTools-spec`. | not covered | | `lanes/repos.tsv:52` | The per-WIP alias override, read by `lanes-edit.sh` as `LANES_REPOS_TSV` (`lanes-edit.sh:2448`). It is byte-identical to the shipped table (sha256 `e4f9160a07ea…`). The only openRepoTools row is `openRepoTools` → `opensoft/openRepoTools`. | There are no `openRepoTools-spec` or `openRepoTools-code` rows, while the IRRS legs have them (`:29-30`, `:34-35`). The table header says an alias not in the table is refused, with a hint to spell owner/repo (shipped `repos.tsv:8`). | not covered | -| handoffs naming the checkout root `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools`: 145 lines (first: `handoffs/openRepoTools/migration-handoff-2026-10-06.md:15, 16, 32`) | Reads, cwd records and commands run in the monorepo checkout. | After cutover, the checkout at that path is the assembly. Code and docs are under `code/` and `spec/` (inferred). | not covered | +| handoffs naming the checkout root `$ORT`: 145 lines (first: `handoffs/openRepoTools/migration-handoff-2026-10-06.md:15, 16, 32`) | Reads, cwd records and commands run in the monorepo checkout. | After cutover, the checkout at that path is the assembly. Code and docs are under `code/` and `spec/` (inferred). | not covered | | `.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-1` (50 lines), `-2` (3), `-3` (59) (first: `migration-handoff-2026-10-06.md:202`; `session-handoff-2026-10-02-lane-openRepoTools-2.md:19`; `session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md:6`) | Lane worktrees are siblings of the lane directory, as monorepo worktrees. | Worktrees made after cutover would be worktrees of leg repositories. The triad protocol puts Speckit features under `/worktrees//{spec,code}` (inferred from the protocol table below). | not covered | | `openRepoTools-worktrees`: 16 lines (first: `migration-handoff-2026-10-06.md:204-206`) | The single-repository Speckit worktree root, `../-worktrees`. | It becomes `/worktrees//{spec,code}` (`openspec-speckit-workflow.md:114`). | not covered (plan.md:207-208, T006, T016-T018) | | `~/projects/openRepoTools/lanes-edit.sh` (and `$HOME/…`): 20 lines (first: `handoffs/xFactory/attachments/opsXfactory-1/briefs/DELTA-land-444-r2.md:9`, `…-r4.md:4`, `…-r5-MERGE-WORKER.md:5`; also `session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md:296`) | Runs the helper from the checkout root. | `lanes-edit.sh` moves to `code/` (path `~/projects/openRepoTools/code/lanes-edit.sh`, inferred). | not covered | | installed-tool paths `~/.local/bin/`: 82 lines in 30 files (first: `README.md:85`, `README.md:86`, `scripts/link-estates:16`); `~/.local/share/openRepoTools/installed.tsv`: 7 lines in 3 files (first: `migration-handoff-2026-10-06.md:17, 57, 114`) | Installed destinations. `README.md:85-86` and `scripts/link-estates:16-17` are the pre-Amendment-9 legacy map from `~/.local/bin/lane-start` and `lane-end` to `brett-wip/lanes/*`. They name no openRepoTools checkout path, and neither do the legacy copies `lanes/{lane-start,lane-end,lanes-edit.sh,test_lane_helpers.sh,README-lanes.md}`. | Destinations are expected to stay the same. | covered: l.75, l.86 | -| host-local `/workspace/projects/.lane-state/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}/trees/*.yaml` (not in git), e.g. `…/openRepoTools-2/trees/c95160057-…-triad-reads.yaml:5` | 37 tree records carry `checkout: /workspace/projects/openRepoTools`. 19 of them have a `path:` under `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools/.claude/worktrees/`, and 18 under `.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-N`, including lane 1's workBenches worktrees (`…wb-image-rebuild-key.yaml:5`). | After cutover, new worktrees are of leg repositories. The checkout is the assembly root (inferred). | not covered | -| `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools/handoffs` → `/workspace/projects/brett-wip/handoffs/openRepoTools` (symlink placed by `link-estates:399-408`) | The checkout root holds an untracked symlink. It is ignored by `.git/info/exclude` (`/handoffs`), not by the tracked `.gitignore` (3 lines). | The assembly root keeps the path (in place, inferred). Its `.gitignore` gets the shape merge (adoption-plan.yaml:338). | not covered | +| host-local `$LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}/trees/*.yaml` (not in git), e.g. `…/openRepoTools-2/trees/c95160057-…-triad-reads.yaml:5` | 37 tree records carry `checkout: $ORT`. 19 of them have a `path:` under `$ORT/.claude/worktrees/`, and 18 under `.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-N`, including lane 1's workBenches worktrees (`…wb-image-rebuild-key.yaml:5`). | After cutover, new worktrees are of leg repositories. The checkout is the assembly root (inferred). | not covered | +| `$ORT/handoffs` → `$BW/handoffs/openRepoTools` (symlink placed by `link-estates:399-408`) | The checkout root holds an untracked symlink. It is ignored by `.git/info/exclude` (`/handoffs`), not by the tracked `.gitignore` (3 lines). | The assembly root keeps the path (in place, inferred). Its `.gitignore` gets the shape merge (adoption-plan.yaml:338). | not covered | ## `~/.agents` and the home directory @@ -221,7 +234,7 @@ openRepoShape pins nothing of openRepoTools. | `protocols/lane-collision-protocol-amendment-9.md:735, 943`; `-11.md:1511`; `-12.md:315`; `-14.md:185`; `-17.md:175`; `-18.md:222` | Name `docs/README-lanes.md` as the tooling's manual. | `docs/` moves to `openRepoTools-spec`. | not covered | | `protocols/lane-collision-protocol.md:659-666`; about 45 lines in amendments 8, 9, 11, 12, 16, 17 and 18 (first: `-8.md:194`, `-9.md:150`, `-11.md:1290`) | Name `openRepoTools --install` as the act that places the lane commands, skills and hooks. | Only the command name and act are read. | covered: l.75 | | `protocols/lane-collision-protocol-amendment-9.md:673, 1000` | `:673`: `--install` runs from the copies vendored at workBenches' `upstream-pin.yaml`. `:1000`: `gh api repos/opensoft/openRepoTools/contents/` returned 404 for files not yet in the repository. | The contents-API paths at the assembly root change. | partial: l.54 covers the fetch. The protocol text is not covered. | -| `protocols/openspec-speckit-workflow.md:114, 279-309`; `protocols/project-agent-bootstrap.md:96-131` | Single-repository `worktree_root: ../-worktrees`. Three-leg layout: `worktree_root: worktrees`, with `/worktrees//{spec,code}`. | openRepoTools's feature worktrees move from `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools-worktrees/` to under the assembly root. | not covered (plan.md:207-208, T006) | +| `protocols/openspec-speckit-workflow.md:114, 279-309`; `protocols/project-agent-bootstrap.md:96-131` | Single-repository `worktree_root: ../-worktrees`. Three-leg layout: `worktree_root: worktrees`, with `/worktrees//{spec,code}`. | openRepoTools's feature worktrees move from `$ORTW/` to under the assembly root. | not covered (plan.md:207-208, T006) | | `protocols/project-agent-bootstrap.md:138-178, 221-226`; `openspec-speckit-workflow.md:57-66` | `setup-openspeckit` detects a triad from `project.yaml`. It writes `.specify/`, managed blocks, opsx commands and skill links at the root, and OpenSpec scaffolding in the spec leg. The first line of `AGENTS.md` is an invariant. The shared checkout's `.specify/`, `.claude/`, `.agents/` and `.codex/` are local and ignored (`.git/info/exclude`). | The bootstrap must be re-run in the assembly root after the legs exist. | not covered (T006; adoption-plan.yaml:346) | | `~/.agents/workspace.yaml:4-5` | `repository: opensoft/brett-wip`, `path: ~/projects/brett-wip`. No openRepoTools path. It is read by `openRepoTools:2211` and by `park`/`resume`. | Nothing in the file. | n/a | | `~/.agents/AGENTS.md:384`; `lane-collision-protocol.md:681`; `-14.md:93` | `${XDG_CONFIG_HOME:-$HOME/.config}/openRepoTools/lanes-index.conf`, a per-workstation configuration path. | Nothing layout-dependent (inferred). | n/a | @@ -304,14 +317,14 @@ Total: 33 rows not covered. A further 7 are partial: workBenches 3, openRepoShap ## Could not read -- **Brett Heap's worktree `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools-worktrees/004-migrate-to-triad`:** not entered, under the hard rule. The plan files were read from lane 2's worktree at the same commit, ff6f6a7. +- **Brett Heap's worktree `$ORTW/004-migrate-to-triad`:** not entered, under the hard rule. The plan files were read from lane 2's worktree at the same commit, ff6f6a7. - **workBenches submodules** (`sysBenches/cloudBench`, which is modified, and `devBenches/*Bench`, `sysBenches/365Bench`): `git grep` at HEAD does not recurse into them. Not read. - **Other writers' trees:** workBenches feature worktrees (`speckit-worktrees/012`–`017`) and lane 1's `wb-*` worktrees. Not read. - **brett-wip:** the 215 untracked entries (`handoffs/xFactory/attachments/lane-opendox/…`) were not read. Commits after `ab88a10` (`466c3a8`, `349caef`) were not read. - **GitHub, live:** no network read was made. Every statement that a URL or contents path would 404 after the split is marked inferred. PR #187 and the #186 record were not read here. - **Raven** and any other workstation: not reachable from this bench. - **`~/.claude-profiles/shared/skills/*` and `shared/commands/*`:** not opened. The receipt shows the same digests as the `~/.claude` copies that were read. -- **`git status` without `--no-optional-locks`** ran in `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools`, `/workspace/projects/workBenches` and `/workspace/projects/brett-wip`. The first two `.git/index` mtimes (`2026-10-07 04:28:20Z`, `2026-10-06 13:08:26Z`) predate this read. brett-wip's (`11:05:49Z`) postdates other writers' commits, and this read ran only `show`, `grep` and `rev-parse` there after 10:06Z. +- **`git status` without `--no-optional-locks`** ran in `$ORT`, `$WB` and `$BW`. The first two `.git/index` mtimes (`2026-10-07 04:28:20Z`, `2026-10-06 13:08:26Z`) predate this read. brett-wip's (`11:05:49Z`) postdates other writers' commits, and this read ran only `show`, `grep` and `rev-parse` there after 10:06Z. ## Gate C follow-up list: outside changes and timing (2026-10-07T11:21Z) @@ -340,20 +353,20 @@ All timings are judged from the reads above. Rows that rest on judgement are mar | S1 | openRepoShape `templates/workspace-root/AGENTS.md:32, 71-76, 91-95`; `README.md:16, 18, 31, 58`; `handoffs/README.md:24`; `lanes/LANES.md:19, 40`; `lanes/log/README.md:4, 6` | yes: openRepoShape (optional template wording) | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | The text names the project slug, which survives; a clause naming the spec leg after the split reads true before and after. It reaches WIP repositories only once the openRepoShape pin openRepoTools carries moves (`openRepoTools:2502-2517`). | | S2 | openRepoShape `scripts/shape_advisory.py:509` | no change (inferred) | — | `resume` still reads `workspace.yaml`, so the docstring stays true. | | S3 | openRepoShape provenance prose (`openRepoShape:19-25, 162`; `README.md:246, 1239`; `docs/handbook.html`; `AGENTS.md:429`; tests) | no change (inferred) | — | The slug survives as the assembly, and the files are still `opensoft/openRepoTools`' at project level. | -| B1 | brett-wip `lanes/log/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}.md` `dir` records (52 lines) | yes: brett-wip, new STARTED/RESUMED lines written by `lane-start`/`lanes-edit.sh`, only if a lane's directory changes at rebinding. In-place adoption keeps `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools` (inferred). | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | The recorded `dir` changes only through a lane rebinding (T018); past lines are history. | +| B1 | brett-wip `lanes/log/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}.md` `dir` records (52 lines) | yes: brett-wip, new STARTED/RESUMED lines written by `lane-start`/`lanes-edit.sh`, only if a lane's directory changes at rebinding. In-place adoption keeps `$ORT` (inferred). | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | The recorded `dir` changes only through a lane rebinding (T018); past lines are history. | | B2 | brett-wip other path-bearing log lines (10) | no change | — | The log is append-only history. | | B3 | brett-wip `lanes/LANES.md:1109, 1303, 2581` | no change (inferred) | — | The rows name brett-wip handoff paths, which do not move. | | B4 | brett-wip `lanes/LANES.md:36` (the other 11 README-lanes lines are dated records) | yes: brett-wip, the `LANES.md:36` header prose | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | A pointer naming the manual by project and by its spec-leg `docs/` location after the split is true in both states. Writes follow the file's HAZARD rule (`:1-8`). | | B5 | brett-wip `lanes/repos.tsv:52` (per-WIP override) | no: openRepoTools only (the shipped table, I3). The override need not change: "an override row … adds rows the shipped table does not carry" (`lanes-edit.sh:2440-2442`). | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | Same reason as I3. | -| B6 | brett-wip handoffs naming `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools` (145 lines) | no change (inferred) | — | In-place adoption keeps the checkout path, and the lines are dated records. | +| B6 | brett-wip handoffs naming `$ORT` (145 lines) | no change (inferred) | — | In-place adoption keeps the checkout path, and the lines are dated records. | | B7 | brett-wip `.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}` lines (112) | no change (inferred) | — | The root is derived from the lane `dir`, which stays; the lines are dated records. | | B8 | brett-wip `openRepoTools-worktrees` lines (16), live in the canonical top blocks `session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md:6`, `…-2026-09-16-lane-openRepoTools-1.md:8`, `…-2026-10-02-lane-openRepoTools-2.md:45` | yes: brett-wip, those top blocks, rewritten by each lane at its next handoff | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | Live feature worktrees move to `/worktrees//{spec,code}` only through T016-T017 translation and T018 rebinding. | | B9 | brett-wip `~/projects/openRepoTools/lanes-edit.sh` lines (20, all in `handoffs/xFactory/**`) | no change | — | All 20 are dated September records. The live hooks use `~/projects/xFactory/lanes-edit.sh`, which points at the installed copy. | -| B10 | host `/workspace/projects/.lane-state/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}/trees/*.yaml` | no: openRepoTools only. These are host files written by `lanes-edit.sh`/`lane-worktrees`, not by hand. | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | Records for leg worktrees can be written only once leg worktrees exist. | -| B11 | host symlink `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools/handoffs` | no outside change. The host's `.git/info/exclude` (`/handoffs`) survives in-place adoption (inferred). An optional root `.gitignore` line would be an openRepoTools change. | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | An ignore line for `/handoffs` is valid in both shapes. | +| B10 | host `$LS/openRepoTools-{1,2,3}/trees/*.yaml` | no: openRepoTools only. These are host files written by `lanes-edit.sh`/`lane-worktrees`, not by hand. | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | Records for leg worktrees can be written only once leg worktrees exist. | +| B11 | host symlink `$ORT/handoffs` | no outside change. The host's `.git/info/exclude` (`/handoffs`) survives in-place adoption (inferred). An optional root `.gitignore` line would be an openRepoTools change. | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | An ignore line for `/handoffs` is valid in both shapes. | | A1 | `~/.agents/AGENTS.md:327, 347-348, 367, 391-392, 419, 430, 443-444, 462, 488, 498` | yes: `~/.agents/AGENTS.md`, only the lines whose code has not landed; landed ones are history | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS (inferred) | A landing can name `openRepoTools-code` only once that repository exists and takes PRs. | | A2 | `~/.agents/protocols/lane-collision-protocol-amendment-9.md:735, 943`; `-11.md:1511`; `-12.md:315`; `-14.md:185`; `-17.md:175`; `-18.md:222` | yes: `~/.agents/protocols` (ratified texts; any edit is the protocol owner's) | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | A pointer naming the manual's location in both shapes is true before and after. | -| A3 | host `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools/.specify/extensions/git/git-config.yml:83` (`worktree_root: ../openRepoTools-worktrees`, ignored) | yes: that host file. The `~/.agents` protocols already describe both layouts (`openspec-speckit-workflow.md:114`). | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | `setup-openspeckit` writes `worktree_root: worktrees` only for a detected three-leg root (`project-agent-bootstrap.md:117, 163`). | +| A3 | host `$ORT/.specify/extensions/git/git-config.yml:83` (`worktree_root: ../openRepoTools-worktrees`, ignored) | yes: that host file. The `~/.agents` protocols already describe both layouts (`openspec-speckit-workflow.md:114`). | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | `setup-openspeckit` writes `worktree_root: worktrees` only for a detected three-leg root (`project-agent-bootstrap.md:117, 163`). | | A4 | host: the checkout root's ignored `.specify/`, `.claude/`, `.agents/`, `.codex/` | yes: those host files, through a `setup-openspeckit` re-run | WAITS FOR REAL LEGS | The bootstrap refuses a manifest whose spec leg is missing or empty (`project-agent-bootstrap.md:242-246`). | | A5 | installed `~/.claude/skills/handoff/SKILL.md:329` | no: openRepoTools only (`skills/handoff/SKILL.md`). It reaches `~/.claude*` through `--install` and workBenches through W1. | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | A third glob `"$dir"/worktrees/*/*` works today: an absent directory fails `[ -d "$worktree" ]` (`:330`) and is skipped. | | I1 | `openRepoTools:1218-1222` (`venv_note` comment) | no: openRepoTools only | ADDITIVE BEFORE CUTOVER (inferred) | A comment can name the manual in both places (adoption-plan.yaml:328 follow-up). | @@ -379,19 +392,19 @@ All timings are judged from the reads above. Rows that rest on judgement are mar - `~/.agents` 2: `AGENTS.md:273-278` stays true through the root entry point, and the `amendment-9.md:673, 1000` text is a dated record. - installer 1: the stale counts in installer-design.md are an openRepoTools-side fix. -**Erratum, no row changed.** The brett-wip row for `~/projects/openRepoTools/lanes-edit.sh` in the table above also cites `session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md:296`. That line names `/workspace/projects/openRepoTools/handoffs/`, not `lanes-edit.sh`. All 20 `lanes-edit.sh` lines are in `handoffs/xFactory/**`. The command used to check this: +**Erratum, no row changed.** The brett-wip row for `~/projects/openRepoTools/lanes-edit.sh` in the table above also cites `session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md:296`. That line names `$ORT/handoffs/`, not `lanes-edit.sh`. All 20 `lanes-edit.sh` lines are in `handoffs/xFactory/**`. The command used to check this: ```sh -git -C /workspace/projects/brett-wip show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:handoffs/openRepoTools/session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md" | sed -n '296p' +git -C $BW show "ab88a10347fb605588643e7ea2e528217dab9a67:handoffs/openRepoTools/session-handoff-2026-09-13-lane-openRepoTools-3.md" | sed -n '296p' ``` The commands this revision added (read-only): ```sh -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | sed -n '2440,2470p' -git -C /workspace/projects/openRepoTools show c4864ac:repos.tsv | sed -n '8,14p;23p' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:lanes-edit.sh | sed -n '2440,2470p' +git -C $ORT show c4864ac:repos.tsv | sed -n '8,14p;23p' grep -n 'missing or empty\|worktree_root: worktrees\|exits non-zero when the manifest' ~/.agents/protocols/project-agent-bootstrap.md grep -n '\[ -d "\$worktree" \]' ~/.claude/skills/handoff/SKILL.md -ls /workspace/projects/openRepoTools/.specify/extensions/git/ -grep -n 'worktree_root\|checkout_mode\|base_branch' /workspace/projects/openRepoTools/.specify/extensions/git/git-config.yml +ls $ORT/.specify/extensions/git/ +grep -n 'worktree_root\|checkout_mode\|base_branch' $ORT/.specify/extensions/git/git-config.yml ``` From c1a30dff628288818916191ad66c0fd1f9537f58 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Brett Heap Date: Sat, 17 Oct 2026 21:00:07 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/5] Durable-intent brainstorm: show the sample restart record's directory as ~/projects/openRepoTools Part of #193 (item 22). The sample record's one illustrative directory was a host-absolute path under the bench root. The home-relative form keeps its meaning, the working directory of the openRepoTools lane the sample names, and passes the hygiene rule. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- .../brainstorm/supervised-context-restart-durable-intent.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/ideation/brainstorm/supervised-context-restart-durable-intent.md b/ideation/brainstorm/supervised-context-restart-durable-intent.md index db083649..60765b83 100644 --- a/ideation/brainstorm/supervised-context-restart-durable-intent.md +++ b/ideation/brainstorm/supervised-context-restart-durable-intent.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ operation_id: state: pending agent: claude profile: team-01l -directory: /workspace/projects/openRepoTools +directory: ~/projects/openRepoTools handoff: handoffs/openRepoTools/session-handoff-2026-09-15-lane-openRepoTools-3.md mode: fresh-from-handoff old_transcript: From 636c5b6865a7e6a9284aa2f83af5982111118516 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Brett Heap Date: Sat, 17 Oct 2026 22:10:10 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 4/5] Hygiene rule: -f names a pattern file, and a path glued onto a scrubbed pattern is still a path Part of #193 (item 22). Findings 1 and 2 of the independent review of #229 (review 5560316525). 1. grep -f '', git grep -f and grep -rf got through: the run of short flags accepted any bundle, so the quoted argument of -f, a pattern FILE and so a path, was scrubbed as if it were the pattern. A bundle that carries a lowercase f is no longer a flag of the run (-F stays one), and the comment now says what the code does about a flag that takes a value. 2. The scrub replaced a pattern with "grep", which ends in a word character, so the root's lookbehind dropped a path glued onto the closing quote. It is now replaced by "grep ". Five REFUSED rows hold them: -f, git grep -f, -rf, -f ahead of an -e chain, and the glued form. Without the fix those five fail and the other 24 new tests pass; with it all 29 pass, the repository scan is clean at head, and main's content still scans to 87 hits in its two files. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- tests/test_repo_hygiene.py | 35 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++------- 1 file changed, 28 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py b/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py index d9adfb34..54a79acc 100644 --- a/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py +++ b/tests/test_repo_hygiene.py @@ -2528,13 +2528,24 @@ def test_readme_is_short_enough_to_be_read(): #: `grep -rn '^path: …'` and `grep -E '…'` (`git grep -n -e '…'` is this #: form too: `-e` reads as one more flag), or #: - the argument of a further `-e`, as in `grep -n -e 'a' -e 'b'`. -#: Everything else stays a finding: a second quoted operand is a FILE (`grep -n -#: 'x' ''`), a double-quoted string can hold a variable, a flag that takes -#: a value (`grep -m 1 '…'`) ends the run of flags, and a path before the -#: `grep` (`git -C grep …`) is outside it. Within a line only: no -#: whitespace in these patterns may be a newline. +#: Everything else stays a finding. The run of flags ends at the first word that +#: is not a short flag, so a flag followed by a bare value (`grep -m 1 '…'`) +#: licenses nothing; and a bundle that carries a lowercase `f` (`-f`, `-rf`) is +#: not a flag of the run at all, because `-f` names a pattern FILE, which is a +#: path and never a pattern (`-F`, fixed strings, is an ordinary flag). Likewise +#: a second quoted operand is a FILE (`grep -n 'x' ''`), a double-quoted +#: string can hold a variable, and a path before the `grep` (`git -C +#: grep …`) is outside it. +#: +#: A scrubbed span is replaced by `grep ` WITH its space: a bare `grep` ends in a +#: word character, and the root's lookbehind would then drop a path glued onto +#: the closing quote. The key is the word `grep`, not a command position, so +#: prose or an `echo` that says `grep '…'` is scrubbed the same way; this is a +#: lexical rule for text a person reviews, not a shell parser. Within a line +#: only: no whitespace in these patterns may be a newline. QUOTED_SEARCH_PATTERNS = re.compile( - r"\bgrep(?:[ \t]+-[A-Za-z]+)*[ \t]+'[^'\n]*'(?:[ \t]+-e[ \t]+'[^'\n]*')*") + r"\bgrep(?:[ \t]+-(?![A-Za-z]*f)[A-Za-z]+)*[ \t]+'[^'\n]*'" + r"(?:[ \t]+-e[ \t]+'[^'\n]*')*") def host_absolute_path_hits(text: str) -> list[str]: @@ -2544,7 +2555,7 @@ def host_absolute_path_hits(text: str) -> list[str]: text is clean.""" hits = HOST_ABSOLUTE_PATH.findall(text) for number, line in enumerate(text.splitlines(), 1): - scrubbed = QUOTED_SEARCH_PATTERNS.sub("grep", line) + scrubbed = QUOTED_SEARCH_PATTERNS.sub("grep ", line) if BENCH_ABSOLUTE_PATH.search(scrubbed): hits.append(f"line {number}: {line.strip()[:120]}") return hits @@ -2984,6 +2995,16 @@ def _plant(template: str) -> str: 'grep -E "projects/x" file'), ("a flag that takes a value ends the run of flags", "grep -m 1 'projects/x' file"), + ("-f names a pattern FILE, which is a path and not a pattern", + "grep -f 'projects/pat.txt' log"), + ("-f under git grep names a pattern file too", + "git grep -f 'projects/pat.txt' HEAD"), + ("-f inside a flag bundle is still -f", + "grep -rf 'projects/pat.txt' ."), + ("-f ahead of an -e chain licenses nothing in it", + "grep -f 'projects/pat.txt' -e 'x' -e 'y' log"), + ("a path glued onto the closing quote of a pattern", + "grep -E 'x'projects/y log"), ("a quoted path piped INTO a grep is still an echoed path", "echo 'projects/x' | grep -n 'y'"), ("a grep on one line licenses nothing on the next", From 08e4249a4a83a2cd00b91d1b8bf6c4080e53f991 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Brett Heap Date: Sat, 17 Oct 2026 23:02:39 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 5/5] consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md: give $READS and $ORTW the file's own words, and say single-quoted Part of #193 (item 22). Lane 2's review of #229 (comment 6242658351), applied inside the added block, which stays 13 lines (5-17). - $READS (requested): the reads ran in lane 2's worktree on its own branch 004-migrate-to-triad-reads, created from the planning branch's commit ff6f6a7, not on the planning branch itself. The definition now says so. - $ORTW (suggested): the root is the single-repository Speckit worktree root, as the file calls it; the definition no longer says more than the evidence. - The note under the list says the hygiene test allows a path inside a single-quoted grep pattern, which is what the rule accepts (a double-quoted pattern and a quoted -f operand are refused). Nothing outside lines 13, 14 and 16 changes; expanding the placeholders and dropping lines 5-17 still reproduces main's file byte for byte. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md b/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md index 5734da37..4d88c86a 100644 --- a/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md +++ b/specs/004-migrate-to-triad/consumer-reads-2026-10-07.md @@ -10,10 +10,10 @@ Bench paths are written as placeholders, defined here once, for the same reason. - `$LS`: the lane-state root, `$PROJECTS/.lane-state`. - `$XF`: the xFactory checkout, `$PROJECTS/xFactory`. - `$ORT`: the openRepoTools checkout, `$PROJECTS/openRepoTools`. -- `$ORTW`: the openRepoTools-worktrees root, where Brett Heap's feature worktrees for openRepoTools live, `$PROJECTS/openRepoTools-worktrees`. -- `$READS`: lane 2's worktree of the planning branch, `$PROJECTS/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads`. +- `$ORTW`: the single-repository Speckit worktree root, `$PROJECTS/openRepoTools-worktrees`. +- `$READS`: lane 2's worktree at the planning branch's commit ff6f6a7 (on lane 2's branch `004-migrate-to-triad-reads`), `$PROJECTS/.lane-worktrees/openRepoTools-2/triad-reads`. -Three recorded searches keep a path inside a single-quoted `grep` pattern exactly as it was typed (the workBenches and brett-wip `grep -e '…'` lines, and the `.lane-state` count), because a placeholder in the pattern would change what was searched for. The hygiene test allows a path inside a quoted `grep` pattern and nowhere else. The paths these placeholders stand for are in lane 2's transcript and in this file as #189 landed it. +Three recorded searches keep a path inside a single-quoted `grep` pattern exactly as it was typed (the workBenches and brett-wip `grep -e '…'` lines, and the `.lane-state` count), because a placeholder in the pattern would change what was searched for. The hygiene test allows a path inside a single-quoted `grep` pattern and nowhere else. The paths these placeholders stand for are in lane 2's transcript and in this file as #189 landed it. Read at 2026-10-07T10:04:44Z–11:07:10Z by lane openRepoTools-2's writer, under #186, from ff6f6a7. An API-side error cut the run, and it resumed at 11:03:49Z, when every head was checked again.